One area that often leaves property owners scratching their heads is the handling of service or assistance animals. Many landlords are confused about what is legally required and what is simply the best practice.
Service animals are not just pets—they play a critical role in the lives of people with disabilities. Federal laws like the Fair Housing Act (FHA) and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) provide clear protections for tenants who rely on these animals.
Failing to follow these regulations puts you at legal risk and can harm your reputation as a landlord. By staying informed and treating tenants fairly, you can create a positive rental experience for everyone involved.
This guide will cover everything you need to know about service animals in Utah to manage these situations confidently.
Difference Between Service Animals and Emotional Support Animals
Many misconceptions revolve around service dogs and emotional support animals; some even mistakenly believe they are similar. However, they have different roles and legal protections. As a landlord in Utah, you must know the differences between the two:
What are Service Animals?
A service animal is a dog that has been individually trained to do work or perform tasks for a person with a disability. They aren't just pets since they undergo specialized training to assist their handlers with specific needs related to their disability. Some of their tasks include:
- Guiding people who are blind
- Alerting people who are deaf
- Pulling a wheelchair
- Assisting with balance
- Providing support during seizures
- Retrieving dropped items
- Alerting people to the presence of allergens
What is an Emotional Support Animal?
An Emotional Support Animal (ESA) is an animal that provides therapeutic benefits to a person with a mental health or psychiatric disability. While dogs are common ESAs, they can also include cats, rabbits, birds, and even some reptiles.
Unlike service animals, an ESA or companion animal doesn't undergo specialized training to perform specific tasks. They primarily provide emotional support, comfort, and companionship to help individuals cope with their mental health conditions.
Landlord's Responsibilities When Allowing Service Animals in Utah's Rental Homes
As a landlord in Utah, understanding your responsibilities regarding service animals is crucial to maintaining a fair and compliant rental environment. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what you need to know:
1. No Discrimination
Under the Fair Housing Act (FHA), housing providers cannot discriminate against tenants with disabilities, which includes those who require service animals. This means that if a tenant has a legitimate need for a service animal, you must allow them to have that animal in your rental property. Discrimination can take many forms, such as refusing to rent to someone because they have a service animal or treating them differently than other tenants.
2. No Pet Restrictions
Standard pet policies, including breed restrictions or "no pets" clauses, do not apply to service animals. The FHA mandates that service animals are allowed regardless of any existing pet policies in your lease agreement.
For instance, typical pet policies, such as breed restrictions (e.g., "no pit bulls"), size limits, or "no pets allowed" rules, do not apply to service animals. This is essential because it ensures that individuals with disabilities have equal access to housing and are not unfairly penalized due to their need for an assistance animal.
Exceptions: If a service animal poses a fundamental alteration to the nature of the housing or poses a direct threat to the health and safety of others, there might be very limited exceptions.
3. No Extra Fees
You cannot charge extra fees for service animals, such as:
- Pet rent: Monthly fees charged for having a pet.
- Pet deposit: Extra security deposits specifically for pets.
- One-time pet fees: Fees charged when a tenant moves in with a pet.
While you can request a security deposit for any damages caused by the animal—provided you apply the same rules to all tenants—you cannot impose additional charges solely because the tenant has a service animal. This aligns with the principles of fair housing and ensures that tenants with disabilities are not financially burdened beyond what is reasonable.
4. Providing Reasonable Accommodations
You must make reasonable changes to your policies, procedures, or property to ensure the tenant can live comfortably. This includes allowing service animals in areas that typically prohibit animals, such as common areas and laundry rooms. You must also modify your rental property to accommodate tenants with mobility challenges.
Important Note: Accommodations should not impose an unreasonable financial or administrative burden on you as the landlord.
5. Rights for Tenant's Verification and Limitations
As a landlord, you have the right to verify the legitimacy of a service animal. You can request documentation confirming that the tenant has a disability and that the animal is necessary for their well-being. A letter from the tenant's doctor or a licensed mental health professional can often be sufficient.
However, it’s important to note that there are some limitations to this, such as:
- You can't demand specific forms (e.g., requiring a specific government-issued document).
- You cannot ask intrusive questions about the nature or severity of the person's disability.
Pro Tip: Focus your verification requests on whether the animal serves its intended purpose without infringing on the tenant's privacy.
6. Considerations on Animal Behavior
Well-behaved service animals must be allowed to remain on your property. The law protects these animals as long as they do not pose an actual threat.
However, if a service animal poses a direct threat to the health and safety of others, you may address this concern appropriately. For example, if an animal exhibits aggressive behavior or disrupts other tenants, you have grounds to take action.
Ensure you follow proper procedures and allow the tenant to address the concerns.
7. Maintaining Common Areas
You are responsible for ensuring that common areas of your property remain accessible and welcoming to all tenants. Maintain common areas in a safe condition for both tenants and their service animals by:
- Keeping walkways clear of obstructions.
- Addressing any safety hazards that could pose a risk to service animals.
- Posting clear signage reminding tenants and guests not to pet or distract them.
In some cases, reasonable modifications to common areas may be needed to ensure accessibility for tenants with service animals. An example of this is installing ramps for wheelchair access or providing designated relief areas for service animals.
8. Addressing Tenant Concerns
Other tenants may express concerns about living near a service or emotional support animal, such as allergies or fear of dogs. While these concerns are valid, they do not override the rights of tenants with disabilities.
You can address these concerns by separating tenants’ living spaces or taking steps to minimize interactions, but you cannot remove or deny a service animal because of another tenant’s preferences.
9. Staying Informed
Federal and state laws regarding service and emotional support animals are constantly evolving. As a landlord, staying informed ensures you comply with the latest rules. You can utilize resources such as:
- State or local government websites, like the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD)
- Fair housing organizations
You can also seek advice from legal professionals or property management experts when faced with complicated situations.
10. Providing Clear Policies
There are pros and cons of allowing pets in rentals. Clear, written policies about service and assistance animals are a proactive way to prevent misunderstandings. Make sure to include in your policies the following:
- Steps tenants should take to request accommodations.
- What type of documentation is required to present.
- Rules regarding animal behavior and tenant responsibilities, like keeping their service or assistance animals under control and cleaning up afterward.
Pro Tip: Regularly review and update your policy to ensure it remains current and compliant with any changes in the law.
11. Training Property Managers
Missteps by property managers could lead to legal complaints, so proper training is essential. So, if you work with property managers or staff, ensure they are trained on handling service and emotional support animal requests. Make sure that they have a thorough understanding of:
- The rights of tenants with service animals.
- Your property's policies regarding service animals.
- How to handle inquiries and concerns from tenants regarding service animals.
Pro Tip: Provide ongoing training to your property managers on any updates to laws or regulations.
Handle Service Animal Requests Like a Pro with Wolfnest
Utah landlords are responsible for ensuring their rental policies align with the law. When it comes to service animals and emotional support animals, getting it right can make all the difference for both your tenants and your property. If you’re unsure where to start or need help managing tenant requests, contact Wolfnest for expert guidance.
Wolfnest offers property management services designed to simplify the process of handling service animals in your rentals:
- Tenant Screening
- Lease Agreement Preparation
- Compliance Guidance
- Conflict Resolution
- Regular Property Inspections
- Ongoing Education
We’ll relieve the pressure so you can focus on growing your investment portfolio while we handle the day-to-day operations. Get a FREE Consultation with us now, and let us take the guesswork out of property management so you can rent with confidence!
Related Articles
Support Animal vs Service Animal: The Laws for Utah Landlords
How to Handle Tenants With Support Animals
The Benefits of Renting to Tenants With Pets
